The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true

TeamSheila2.0, 4/23/2024, 10:55AM(10 days ago)

I think the woman Steffy stabbed was Sugar and Sheila is alive. Don't know all the details yet but the real Sheila will be back. I have always believed that. But now I'm seeing a lot of theories suggesting that Sugar is Finn's mother and that she was pretending to be Sheila the entire time. How is that possible? The Sheila from 2021-2023 had numerous discussions about her past with Brooke, Taylor, Steffy and especially Bill. She had very detailed flashbacks of when she shot Brooke and Taylor. During the Halloween episode with Deacon, she had detailed flashbacks of some catfights with Lauren and Stephanie. Flashbacks from the 1990s. She told Bill very specific details about Dr Gavin and Lance's death. Sugar appeared on canvas in 2003. Dr Gavin fell off the balcony a DECADE earlier, in 1994. Only the real Sheila Carter could remember those details and produce such flashbacks.

I think Sheila's return will be the final nail in the coffin for Steffy's marriage. Especially when she finds out Finn investigated and still has conflictual feelings about his mother. She left Finn for several months when she learnt he hugged Sheila, imagine her reaction after this reveal. She will go back to Liam, I'm more convinced than ever after watching her last interactions with him. She loves both men, but she is still choosing Finn today because she sees him as this paragon of virtue who hates Sheila and could never have eyes for another woman. Her faith in him will be shattered. Finn will probably try with Hope next. Seeds are planted for a Thope-Fope triangle but unless he can completely forget about Steffy and be a one-woman man, she will choose Thomas. What's next for Finn? A triangle with Bill and Poppy? Ivy ? Katie ? Donna ?

506 views report

chat Reply

bookmark Save

Show complete thread:

RSS Feed of thread

The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - TeamSheila2.0, 4/23/2024, 10:55AM
- The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - Tiqui1999, 4/23/2024, 11:20AM
- The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - theduchess, 4/23/2024, 11:23AM
- The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - howeveryouknow, 4/23/2024, 11:41AM
- The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - dxdobson, 4/23/2024, 11:44AM
- The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - KLaw27, 4/23/2024, 2:10PM
  - The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - Tiqui1999, 4/23/2024, 2:14PM
  - The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - Kammie, 4/23/2024, 4:14PM
    - The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - Sammy, 4/23/2024, 4:20PM
- The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - Soapyfun41, 4/23/2024, 5:10PM
  - The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - Sammy, 4/23/2024, 5:31PM
    - The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - B&Bfan1980, 4/23/2024, 5:57PM
- The theory that Sheila was Sugar all along can't be true - CBSsoapfan, 4/23/2024, 7:41PM